HR tries to discipline employee for missing a meeting they weren't invited to, double down when their mistake is revealed: 'What do they want me to do? Telepathically sense meetings?'

Author image for JR Atkinson
JR Atkinson • Writer and Editor
Dec 9, 2025 10:00 AM EST

Everyone makes mistakes, but what matters is how you respond when you realize you're wrong. Nobody can avoid making errors over the course of their life or their career. It's simply inhuman and impossible. So don't sweat the small stuff. What you can sweat, though, is how you react. You can either admit your wrongdoing, apologize, and move on (correct course of action), or you can double down on your mistake as to appear infallible, burning bridges and losing credibility in the process. There is a clear answer here, but that doesn't mean we're always up to the task. Sometimes it feels too difficult to apologize.

That's the situation this HR manager was in after they tried to call out an employee for missing a meeting. When it was revealed, though, that in fact the meeting had never crossed the employee's desk, they refused to back down. Instead of just admitting their mistake and letting the employee off the hook, they refused to say they were wrong. This left the employee in an impossible situation where they ended up punished for something they never did.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A man in a suit looks incredulous at a woman across from him at work.
    via Vitaly Gariev

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Would you apologize for something that you know wasn't your fault? You would hate to be put in this situation in the first place, but it happens more than you might think. This employee was left reeling after a one-on-one with HR that revealed some interesting mistakes. Read on to see what happened and what commenters had to say. 

  • HR tried to 'discipline' me for not attending a meeting... that they forgot to invite me to.

    So last Thursday I got pulled into a "quick chat" with HR and my manager. Never a good sign. They tell me I "failed to attend a mandatory quarterly operations meeting" and that this was my second "missed meeting" this quarter. I'm already confused because I literally attend every meeting on my calendar. I'm that person who shows up 5 minutes early with a notebook.
    via u/Ornery_Lynx8610
  • They pull up this mysterious meeting invite. Except... I never got it. Not in email, not in Teams, not in spam, not in deleted. It simply never existed for me. I told them this nicely and HR gives me the condescending "Well, everyone else got it." So I opened my laptop and asked them to pull up the attendee list on their end.
    via u/Ornery_Lynx8610
  • My name wasn't there. At all. I wasn't invited. Then my manager goes, "But we verbally announced it in the team huddle." Nope. I wasn't even in that huddle, I was at a client site that morning and he signed the field visit approval himself. So he absolutely knew I wasn't there.
    via u/Ornery_Lynx8610
  • Then HR tries to pivot: "Well, it is still your responsibility to stay informed." About meetings I'm not included in...? At this point my patience had fully clocked out for the day. I just said: "I'm happy to attend any meeting you invite me to. If you don't invite me, you can't discipline me for not attending."
    via u/Ornery_Lynx8610
  • Somehow I walked out of that room with a "verbal warning" for "communication gaps." I'm still stunned. Like... what do they want me to do? Telepathically sense meetings?
    via u/Ornery_Lynx8610

  • Other workers chimed in with their thoughts.

    jdsav29 6d ago They are trying to come up with excuses to put you on a PiP or fire you. Print out documents, keep a notebook of the bs, and look for another job.
    via u/jdsav29
  • A man in a suit with a clipboard talks to a woman across from him at work.
    via Vitaly Gariev

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • . jadanas • 6d ago I cannot believe they had the hide to double down instead of just apologize for the misunderstanding. I would be outraged. I AM outraged and I'm not even you.
    via u/jadanas
  • fhb29 6d ago send an email immediately and recap the whole meeting in the email include ur boss his boss and hr
    via u/fhb29
  • LuckyWriter1292 · 6d ago I would put it back on to them - complain to their bosses. your boss is a snake. -
    via u/LuckyWriter1292
  • Otherwise-Cry-4695 · 6d ago Communication gap?? The gap is you communicating with them at all after that clown show. Document everything and keep your receipts, friend. They tried to invent a meeting AND blame you for it.
    via u/Otherwise-Cry-4695
  • sdsva 6d ago . You should schedule a daily weekday reoccurring event asking if there are any meetings you need to attend that you won't be invited to. Invite your manager and the HR rep. Request a response and If they object, ask for advice on how to better bridge the communication gap.
    via u/sdsva
  • Echo Equani • 6d ago It seems like they're setting you up for failure and they might be trying to slowly get rid of you or fire you.
    via u/EchoEquani
  • . Spiritual-Courage-77 • 6d ago Why can't people admit that they made a mistake anymore??? All they had to say was something like "oh my bad!! I'll add you to the invite now. I'll make sure everyone knows you were not on the invite. Again, sorry for the mix up."
    via u/Spiritual-Courage-77
  • Instead they double down and look/sound even more ridiculous while trying to turn it around on you! Isn't that a piss poor attempt at gaslighting?? Being someone that is getting excluded from everything but expected to read minds and know what was discussed, be careful as something is going on.
    via u/Spiritual-Courage-77
  • Snowfizzle 6d ago • that sounds like the stuff they used to pull at my previous job. they dud verbals because they couldn't actually put anything in writing because i'd have to sign it. and then that would need to be explained and they knew they were wrong.
    via u/Snowfizzle
  • one thing they did stupidly put in writing and then let me know after they had cooled down that oh hey by the way, this can be removed from your personnel folder after a year No, no, I'm going to leave that crazy write up in there. it's the only one and anyone who ever gets to read it will see what BS it is and which supervisor put it in there. he wasn't well liked anyways.
    via u/Snowfizzle
  • CozJeez85 • 6d ago . Start sending a email first thing in the morning to your boss and CC in HR. "Good morning, please reply to this email to state formally in writing any meetings which you wish for me to attend" Do it daily, until HR tells you to knock it off and takes the absurd warning off your record.
    via u/CozJeez85
  • • HotRod Homebody 6d ago They sound like dysfunctional idiots. ' might be wise to check out other job opportunities. Especially if they're going to die on that hill.
    via u/HotRodHomebody
  • manxbean 6d ago . I mean, if I'm going to be annoyed at someone not doing something you'd better be sure I'm going to check all my receipts to ensure I'm justified in being pissed off. How no one looked at the invite to see if you'd actually received it before inviting you to that meeting is absolutely wild to me
    via u/manxbean
  • bingle-cowabungle 6d ago The very first thing you should have done after that meeting is document literally everything that was discussed, including the fact that you still received a "verbal warning" for attending a meeting you were excluded from.
    via u/bingle-cowabungle
  • AutomaticRepeat2... • 6d ago The moment you proved you were not invited was a good moment to say: I understand this is an awkward situation. Mistakes happen and, as long as we learn from them and correct them, we can be mature enough to admit them. It is ok that you missed
    via u/AutomaticRepeat2
  • my name in the attendee list of the meeting. Can I please receive notes from the meeting so I can review offline? Also, if you can please make sure to include me in future meetings I will absolutely make it a priority to attend. Thank you for your time, I will get back to work for now but I will be here to answer any other questions you might have.
    via u/AutomaticRepeat2
  • Coffee-n-chardonn... • 6d ago I would definitely ask your manager every single day going forward if there are any meetings you should attend that day outside of the meetings you were invited to.
    via u/Coffee-n-chardonnay
  • ExtremeAthlete • 6d ago . "Can we repurpose this meeting to discipline the person who didn't invite me?"
    via u/ExtremeAthlete
  • III_... . • 6d ago Edited 6d ago Haha! Had the exact same thing happen to me to a T! It didn't get better from there. By the time they have HR included a decision has already been made somewhere.
    via u/Ill_Roll2161
  • • kngwall 6d ago Do you remember when you were in middle school those students that studied so hard, underlined everything in all colors and always stressed out others asking if they studied for the test? And then proceeded to get fairly mediocre grades anyway? They work in HR now.
    via u/kngwall
  • WideConfidence39... . 6d ago I was once told in an appraisal that they couldn't score me 100% attendance because I hadn't been there long enough. I think it was about 10 months, certainly 100% up to that point - I made sure to write it on the hard copy that I disagreed with it.
    via u/WideConfidence3968
  • iluvcats17 · 6d ago Your boss wants you out. I would work hard to find another job before they find another excuse to get rid of you.
    via u/iluvcats17
  • Solid_Milk3104 · 6d ago . Document the meeting you had. Follow up with a email with your boss, HR and your bosses boss apologizing for the missed meeting and request going forward that you will personally acknowledge and confirm all meeting invites so there will
    via u/Solid_Milk3104
  • not be any confusion if you received an invitation going forward. Suggest that the meetings be added to a shared calendar so you can visually check for meetings and plan your schedule accordingly.
    via u/Solid_Milk3104

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss antiwork workplace-stories hr toxic-workplace job meeting bosses work coworkers working reddit story human resources workplace reddit thread Reddit discipline toxic-work-environment
Scroll Down For The Next Article